Introduction
Finding a dog treat that’s not only tasty but also nutritious can be tricky, especially when you have dogs with different dietary needs. I recently tested the Boxby Cold Pressed Duck Dog Treats with my two boxers, Lando and Nico, during a walk at Newborough Beach. These treats, made with natural ingredients and marketed as grain-free, seemed like a promising option. Here’s how they stacked up in the PawScore rating system.
Product Overview
The Boxby Cold Pressed Duck Treats are designed for both puppies and adult dogs, with an emphasis on natural ingredients and single-protein sources. The 100g pack features a no-grain recipe, making it suitable for dogs with sensitivities or allergies. Duck is the primary ingredient, which provides a high-protein, low-fat snack option.
- Grain-Free: Ideal for dogs with grain sensitivities.
- Single Protein: Duck as the sole animal protein source.
- Cold Pressed: Helps preserve essential nutrients.
PawScore Ratings
| Category | Score (Out of 10) |
|---|---|
| Taste Appeal | 9 |
| Nutritional Value | 8 |
| Texture & Digestibility | 7 |
| Ingredient Transparency | 9 |
| Value for Money | 9 |
| Total PawScore | 42/50 |
1. Taste Appeal (9/10):
Lando and Nico absolutely loved the taste. Lando, my mischievous young boxer, practically wagged his whole body when he smelled these. Even Nico, who can be picky with new treats, was quick to devour them. Based on their reactions, I’m giving it a near-perfect score for taste appeal.
2. Nutritional Value (8/10):
The treats boast a good balance of protein and fats from the duck, without any grains or fillers. However, they could benefit from added vitamins or minerals for even more nutritional punch.
3. Texture & Digestibility (7/10):
While Lando had no issue chomping down on these, Nico seemed to take a bit longer to chew, and I noticed that some pieces crumbled more than others. Still, neither dog had any tummy issues, which is a huge win in my book.
4. Ingredient Transparency (9/10):
Boxby lists all ingredients clearly, and I love that they focus on simple, natural elements like duck and vegetable glycerin without any unnecessary additives.
5. Value for Money (9/10):
Priced at £2.99 for 100g, these treats are affordable, especially considering the high-quality ingredients. The pricing is competitive with other natural, grain-free options on the market.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Great taste, well-loved by my two boxers.
- Grain-free, ideal for dogs with sensitivities.
- Affordable price for a natural, high-quality product.
Cons:
- Some inconsistencies in texture and crumbliness.
- Could use added vitamins for more nutritional value.
Personal Experience
We tested these treats on a sunny day at Newborough Beach in Wales. The pack fit easily into my pocket, and the dogs were thrilled every time I pulled one out. Lando, my high-energy boxer, loved jumping around to grab the treat, while Nico sat patiently for his turn. Despite the crumbliness I noticed, both dogs seemed to thoroughly enjoy the texture and flavor.
The treats also held up well on our longer walks, as I didn’t have to worry about greasy residue or them falling apart in my pocket, which has happened with other brands in the past. I was especially impressed with how quickly both dogs took to the new treat, given that Nico can sometimes be fussy.
Comparison with Competitors
Compared to other natural, grain-free treats like those from Lily’s Kitchen and James Wellbeloved, Boxby holds its own in terms of both taste and pricing. While Lily’s Kitchen treats might offer a slightly broader range of ingredients and added vitamins, Boxby provides a great balance of affordability and quality. It’s also notable that Boxby emphasizes single-protein treats, which is ideal for dogs with specific dietary needs, a point where it stands out against James Wellbeloved.
| Brand | Grain-Free | Price | Rating |
|---|---|---|---|
| Boxby | Yes | £2.99 for 100g | 4.5/5 |
| Lily’s Kitchen | Yes | £3.50 for 100g | 4.7/5 |
| James Wellbeloved | Yes | £3.00 for 100g | 4.6/5 |
Expert Opinions
Veterinarians often recommend natural, grain-free treats for dogs with sensitivities, and Boxby seems to meet those standards. Dr. Jane Robertson, a UK-based veterinarian, emphasizes the importance of single-protein treats for dogs prone to allergies, noting that duck is often a gentler protein for sensitive stomachs.
Final Verdict
Overall, the Boxby Cold Pressed Duck Treats scored well across the board, especially in taste appeal and ingredient transparency. While the texture could be improved, it’s a minor issue considering the dogs loved them and there were no digestive concerns. If you’re looking for an affordable, natural treat that’s easy on sensitive tummies, these are a great option!
PawScore: 42/50 ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Recommendation: Definitely worth trying, especially if you have a dog with dietary sensitivities.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the Boxby Cold Pressed Duck Treats are a solid choice for pet owners who want to feed their dogs something healthy, tasty, and free from grains. If your pup enjoys a rich, duck-flavored treat, give these a try! You can find them online at Jollyes.
